Could Potash Be a trade War Weapon for Trump Tariffs? Experts urge caution
Potash could become a potent weapon in a growing trade war as Canada vowed to fight back against sweeping tariffs that U.S. President Donald Trump put into effect on Tuesday, but economists urged caution.
Potash is a key ingredient in fertilizer, and about 85 percent of the potash used by U.S. farmers comes from Canada, particularly Saskatchewan, where potash is a major export market.
U.S. farm groups and even some Republicans aligned with Mr. Trump have called for an exemption from the full potash tariff because of concerns about agriculture.
Ontario Premier Doug Ford told reporters on Tuesday that Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe should consider moving away from selling potash, uranium and oil to the United States and instead look to different markets.
Doug Ford: "We need to make sure America feels the pain. Without potash, there is no agricultural system in the United States."
Announcing the first round of retaliating tariffs on U.S. products, Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said Canada would also consider non-tariff measures if necessary, but did not directly answer when asked if Ottawa would limit potash or crude oil exports.
Moe has previously opposed the idea of restricting Canadian energy to the United States, and Canadian countermeasures should not unduly hurt any one province.
He said in a statement on Tuesday that his cabinet would meet on Wednesday to "consider all options" to respond to the US tariffs, and renewed calls to reduce inter-provincial trade barriers and promote the development of pipelines and other infrastructure.
"American farmers need Canadian fuel and fertilizer to grow their crops," Moe said. Trump's tariffs will drive up the cost of oil, potash and uranium, which will drive up the cost of groceries for every American family."
Even with potash prices falling in 2023, Saskatchewan exported more than $11.5 billion worth of potash that year. Almost all production is sold to other countries, accounting for a third of global production. Russia and Belarus, the second largest producers, account for another third, followed by China.
Canada's fertilizer industry says U.S. tariffs not only threaten food production and security on both sides of the border, but will also drive U.S. farmers toward those countries.
"Imposing U.S. tariffs on Canadian Fertilizer imports would distort the U.S. market in favor of countries like Russia and China that operate differently under environmental, human rights, and trade practices, undermining key trade goals for each of our countries," said a statement from Fertilizer Canada.
But Corey Rosenbusch, president and chief executive of the Fertilizer Institute in Denver, Colorado, said those countries would not be able to fill the gap left if the American agricultural industry stopped using potashcorp.
"The world doesn't have enough supply to completely replace it," he said in an interview. "Even with the tariffs, we still need Potashcorp."
Nutrien, one of Saskatchewan's largest potash producers, warned that U.S. farmers would eventually feel the cost of the tariffs. Nutrien has been engaging with policymakers and stakeholders in the U.S. and Canada to make the case against the tariffs.
Other companies, many of them foreign, that mine potash in Saskatchewan declined requests for interviews or comment on Tuesday.
Farmers were able to import enough potash and other fertilizer products when the tariffs were temporarily suspended in February to prepare for the spring planting season, which has begun in some states, Rosenbusch said.
But importers have seen prices rise because of the uncertainty and some have had to switch to Russian potash because of high demand, he said.
He added that 60 percent of the potash used in the U.S. each year is applied in the fall, meaning farmers will soon feel the impact of the tariffs in the coming months.
Agriculture industry groups such as the American Farm Bureau Federation say farmers have suffered losses on most staple crops for three straight years amid high global inflation and supply chain constraints, and tariffs have further compounded those woes.
In February, before Mr. Trump first announced the tariffs on Canada and Mexico, but before they were temporarily halted, Senator Chuck Grassley, a Republican from Iowa, a key agricultural state, said he was pushing for potash to be exempt from the additional tariffs, also pushed by fertilizer and farm groups.
Asked on Tuesday whether he was still seeking a potash exemption, a spokesman for the senator pointed to Mr. Grassley's comments to reporters that he was on the fence about Mr. Trump's tariffs.
"I'm still a free and fair trader," he said. "The president won the election on the basis that he would impose tariffs and maybe it would work (reducing or eliminating global tariffs).
Brooke Rollins, the US agriculture secretary, told reporters on Sunday that she had raised the issue of increased potash import costs with Mr Trump and other administration officials "and will continue to do so".
Economists say cutting off potash exports to the US would lead to unnecessary upgrades and threaten food supplies in both countries.
"I see a much greater risk of a negative impact, but in terms of public perception in the U.S. and indirect perception in Canada, that would make me hesitant to use potash," "Said Werner Antweiller, professor and chair of international trade policy studies at the University of British Columbia.
Canada imported $32 billion of agricultural goods from the U.S. in 2023, and many of those items are now subject to Canadian anti-tariffs.
Carol McAusland, a professor of land and food systems at the University of British Columbia, said an export tax on potash destined for the United States would be a better strategy. That would further raise prices for U.S. farmers but ensure Canada collects some of the money, she said.
Article source: voiceofglobe compilation: Agrochemical era
Disclaimer: This platform is neutral to the content, statement and opinion judgment reproduced and shared, and does not provide any express or implied guarantee for the accuracy, reliability or completeness of the content contained. It is for readers' reference only, and this public platform will not assume any responsibility. Part of the content from the Internet, the copyright belongs to the original author, only for learning reference, if there is infringement, please contact to delete.
This article is reprinted from the wechat official account of AGROCHEMICALTIMES (ID: AGROCHEMICALTIMES)
Related news
Shandong Yurun Chemical Co.,Ltd
Address:Yurun Building,Gaoxin District,Weifang City,Shandong Province,China
Tel:+86-(0)536-8164977 Fax:+86-(0)536-8164988